The Cost of Poor Leadership Coaching Skills

A plant manager called me in with a problem he could see every single day. Production held strong through most of a shift, then slipped hard every time one crew handed off to the next. The handoffs between shifts were where his plant was quietly losing ground.
When we sat down together, we chose one behaviour to work on. Not ten. One. We wanted his leaders to move from competing with the other shifts to collaborating with them.
It was the first time this team had ever invested in leadership development. Over five months, we worked with the leaders on how they treated their crews: helping people feel safe, seen, heard and valued, connecting them to why great work mattered, and setting them up to succeed. We challenged the leaders to think ahead and to think reciprocally, to care about the shift coming in after them as much as their own.
Halfway through the third month, the plant hit a record production day.
I still smile when I think about that moment. Nothing about that program was soft. It went straight at the plant manager's biggest pain point, and the results showed up exactly where he needed them, in smoother handoffs and steadier output across a full 24 hours.
Another client brought me in because they had built an excellent apprenticeship program, and their apprentices kept leaving the moment they graduated. All that investment, walking out the door. As we dug in, the leaders began to recognize something hard to admit. They did not know how to reach this next generation. Nobody had ever taught them how to coach, or how to build the kind of relationship that makes a young person want to stay.
We worked together for two and a half years. By the end, the leaders mentoring those apprentices were keeping them, so well that the company could staff everything it needed. The way apprentices talked about their supervisors and mentors changed drastically. Near the end, one of those leaders said to me, "It feels so different on the floor, and it's pretty great."
I hear a lot of pushback on this work. It's soft. It's nice to have. It isn't backed by numbers. I understand where that comes from, and I will admit it frustrates me, because what I usually hear underneath it is that we are not measuring the right numbers to understand the true cost. The cost of poor leadership coaching skills is real. It just rarely gets its own line in the budget. It hides in resignations and recruiting invoices, in a project that slipped, in the shift change that loses output every single day.
These are invisible costs, quietly leaking valuable resources out of an organization. I think of culture as the oil in the engine. You hardly notice it when it is there. You notice very quickly when it is gone.
I am not counting the cost to turn people into line items. I count it because it is one way of taking people seriously. Care for the people first, and the plan receives the benefit. I know how many leaders are carrying real pressure to deliver, with targets that do not soften just because a team is tired. Nothing here asks you to choose between your people and your results. The first tends to serve the second.
Of all the research I read this year, one number stopped me. DDI's Global Leadership Forecast 2025 found that only 30 percent of leaders feel they have enough time to carry out their responsibilities with the depth and care they require. Seventy-one percent say their stress has gone up significantly since stepping into their current role.
That tells me exactly why the people-work gets pushed aside. It is messy, and it takes time.
When a leader is already stretched thin, the conversation that could change everything for someone on their team is the first thing to slide off the overflowing plate I wrote about earlier this month.
The wider research tells the same story on a bigger scale. Gallup's State of the Global Workplace 2026 report found that global employee engagement fell to 20 percent in 2025, down from its 2022 peak of 23 percent and the lowest level since 2020. Gallup estimates that low engagement cost the world economy about $10 trillion in lost productivity last year, roughly 9 percent of GDP. Most of that recent drop comes from managers. Their engagement fell from 31 percent in 2022 to 22 percent in 2025, while engagement among people who do not manage others moved from 20 percent to 19 percent. Trust is slipping too. DDI found that leaders' trust in their own immediate managers fell from 46 percent in 2022 to 29 percent in 2024. The people we count on to hold everyone else up are wearing thin.
There is hope in these numbers too. In Gallup's best-practice organizations, 79 percent of managers are engaged, nearly four times the global average, so this decline is not inevitable. DDI found that employees whose managers are effective coaches are nine times more likely to trust their manager. On the other side, high-potential people are 2.7 times more likely to leave within a year when their manager is not an effective coach. Research like this shows patterns rather than guarantees, since no single study can untangle every reason one organization thrives and another struggles. Still, it points in the same direction I see on the floor.
Of the leaders whose stress has climbed, DDI found that 54 percent worry about burnout and 40 percent have thought about stepping away from leadership altogether. These things will break, and when they break, they cost us. The real question is whether we are willing to step in before it is too late. That means making the case for shifting how work gets done, so there is room for people, so the work can actually get done.
If you are the one trying to make that case to your CFO, I know how lonely it can feel to argue for something people call soft. That is exactly why I built the Culture Cost Calculator™ . It asks for your number of employees, average annual salary, annual revenue, estimated legal costs, the estimated percentage of disengaged staff, the estimated number of leaders on leave, and the estimated number of people carrying too much. You do not need exact figures. Estimates from what you already know will give you a real starting point.
When I walk leaders through it, I always ask what they notice when they see their number for the first time. Most often it is a shock. Sometimes it is sadness, a quiet "Oh man, I didn't realize this was where we were." Right behind that, there is often a feeling of powerlessness, not knowing where to start or how to recover what has been lost. If that is where you land, you are not alone, and it is not the end of the story. It is the beginning of a much more honest conversation.
If you are ready to take a first step, Flourishing Workplace Champions™ has a new cohort starting in January. It is a year to invest in your frontline leaders, managers and supervisors, so they can coach, grow their skills, and lead culture in a way people actually feel on the floor.
Next week, in the last blog this month, I want to come back to that overflowing plate, and why even the most caring leaders struggle to coach when there is no room left to do it.
Until then, something to ponder. If you could see the cost of your last resignation on a single page, what would you want to understand first?




Comments