top of page

The Real Cost of Unspoken Rules

nstraza
Oct 30
4 min read
Leader with a magnifying glass highlighting the word "costs"

Four weeks ago I started writing about the rules nobody writes down at work, the ones nobody actually agreed to, but everyone somehow gets held to anyway.


Week 1

We covered the rule that good employees just "figure it out", the expectation that competence includes reading between the lines.


Week 2

We explored the assumption that the org chart or the process document already explains what someone needs to know, so saying it out loud feels redundant.


Week 3

We raised awareness about the belief that if you need something explained, you're not ready for the job, and we talked about a shift team I worked with directly. Before training, the crews were competing against each other without saying so, guarding information, treating shift change like a handoff between rivals. Once we made the unspoken expectations explicit, describing what "good" looked like, how work should move between shifts, what collaboration actually meant in practice, the team's behaviour shifted from guarded to genuinely cooperative. A few weeks later the plant manager pulled me aside to point out a production record on the board.


That happened because people stopped guessing at expectations and started working from shared ones. This dovetails into our next unspoken rule.

Week 4

We looked at the unspoken assumption that people should already know what good looks like without being told, using a story from my own house: my toddler, asked to bring me a dish, brought me a toy instead, because I had never actually told her which dish. I had assumed "the dish" was specific in a way it wasn't to them. Adults do this to each other constantly.

We assume our own internal picture of "good" is obvious to everyone else, then we get frustrated when someone hands us a different, equally reasonable interpretation of it.

Now for the part that costs money.

No leader is running a team on just one of these four rules. Most teams run on some mix of all four, spread across different people, at the same time (not to mention the ones we haven't even talked about).


As one illustration, imagine this very real and likely scenario in a typical workplace in 2026: a Gen X operations lead who assumes competence means minimal hand-holding, working next to a Boomer VP who trusts the process document to do explaining work it was never built to do, a Millennial coordinator who learned early in her career that asking clarifying questions wasn't welcome and still doesn't ask them, and a Gen Z apprentice who grew up with explicit, step-by-step instruction and reads silence as either trust or neglect, without always being able to tell which.


None of this means a generation behaves a fixed way. Generational dynamics is not about stereotyping but rather about context. The Generational lens gives us understanding as to why a pattern might exist in a given person, not a rule for how that person will act. The lens helps you notice where an unspoken rule might be operating.


So the leader's job isn't to pick one management style and apply it evenly across a team. It's to notice which unspoken rule is running underneath each relationship and adjust the instruction accordingly. That's a different skill than "communicate more clearly," which is vague advice on its own.


It's closer to figuring out what this specific person assumes you've already told them, then checking our own facts and putting our own assumptions on trial.

This matters financially as much as relationally.

When a new hire or apprentice doesn't know what's expected of them, and doesn't feel safe enough (or doesn't think it's allowed) to ask, they don't ramp at the rate you budgeted for. Time to productivity stretches. Output during that stretch runs lower than what you're paying for. A meaningful number of them leave before they ever reach full productivity, which means the training investment you made in them walks out the door unrecovered.

Then there's the replacement cost on top of that: recruiting, onboarding, and a new ramp period that starts from zero, sometimes for a person operating under a different unspoken rule than the last one, which means the same clarity gap can produce the same expensive outcome twice.

I pay attention to this especially with young apprentices and new hires in skilled trades and technical roles, where the training investment per person is real money and the retention window is short enough that a few unclear weeks at the start can decide whether that investment ever pays off.


If you want to see what this is actually costing your team, the Culture Cost Calculator on my website will walk you through it in a few minutes. It isn't a sales pitch. It's a way to put an actual number next to a pattern most leaders can already feel but haven't priced out.



This is also part of why I built the Clear Commitment Process, made up of the Clear Conversation Model, the Commitment Map, and the Pulse Check, and why the Flourishing Workplace Champions program exists. Not because clear instruction is a nice-to-have, but because unclear instruction has a bill attached, one that most organizations are paying every quarter without ever seeing the invoice.


Thanks for joining me this month!


Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

© 2022 by Nicki Straza

bottom of page