Coaching for the Plan or Coaching for the People?

I left a job I was good at, and a team I cared about, when I had very little left to give either one.
When I reflect, I can trace how I got there, and it began with being good at doing. I worked my way up the ranks as a strong doer, the kind of person who sees what needs to happen and makes it happen, and each time I delivered, another promotion followed. Those promotions felt like confirmation that I was on the right path, so I kept saying yes. Yes to the next project, yes to the added responsibility, yes to the thing nobody else seemed to have room for. I was a people-pleaser by nature, and I cared deeply about the mission we were serving, which meant every request arrived with a good reason attached. It is hard to say no to something you believe in, and harder still when saying yes is the way you have always been valued.
My plate kept getting fuller, and I kept finding it difficult to say so. I have thought a great deal about why asking for what I needed felt so out of reach, and I still don't have a tidy answer. What I do know is that my leader was consumed with accomplishing and growing the mission, and that devotion was real. It also meant that more kept landing on my plate, and on the plates of the people around me, at a cost to us that nobody was counting. Somewhere in the middle of all that, I began to burn out.
In time, I found enough of my voice to advocate for my own bandwidth, for some space to breathe, and for the ability to say no. I also spoke up for my whole team of volunteers, who were giving so generously and deserved to have their capacity treated as something precious. I did not do any of this gracefully or with much confidence, but I did it, because I could see what the pace was asking of all of us.
My leader was good at asking a particular question, and I want to give credit for that, because it was asked kindly and with what seemed like real interest: "What's getting in the way?" I answered each time honestly. I said the volume of to-dos was too high, and that if we truly wanted to care for people, our strategic priorities would need to change. My leader was not good at hearing that kind of feedback, and so the plan stayed exactly as it was. The question was asked and answered, and the list stayed just as long as before.
Through all of those conversations, nobody was willing to change the plan in service of what people needed, myself included.
People began to leave. Volunteers went first, then leaders, and then, eventually, I went too. I should say that this was not the only reason I left, and there are other reasons I won't get into here, but this was a real part of it, and it is the part I keep returning to because I think it has something to teach.
I want to be fair to my leader. Anyone carrying that much pressure for a mission they love is going to reach for whatever helps the work move forward, and I believe the intent behind that question was most likely good. Plenty of leaders ask what is in the way because they sincerely want to clear the path.
The trouble is that a question about obstacles points attention toward the plan, while a question about needs points attention toward the person, and those two questions open very different conversations.
This is what I am learning about coaching skills. They are not neutral, and a well-phrased question does not automatically make someone feel cared for. People can tell, usually within moments, whether a question is for them or for the plan. When it is for the plan, they learn to answer in ways that keep things moving, or they stop answering at all. When it is for them, something in the whole relationship begins to change.
And let's be clear: it's not an either-or question but rather a first-then question.
When we put people before task and our people feel cared for, they rise to high performance and do great work. So we aren't neglecting our strategic plan when we coach for the well-being of people first. We are ensuring its success.
I sometimes wonder what a simple Pulse Check™ might have shown us along the way. It is a short, regular check on how a commitment is holding up and what needs to change, and it would have given me a natural place to say how things were really going for me, and perhaps for the volunteers too, well before the leaving began. It would not have solved everything, but it might have given the plan a chance to bend toward the people carrying it.
This month I am exploring why coaching skills belong in every leadership role, not only in the formal coaching conversations that happen on a calendar, but in the everyday moments when a leader decides what to ask and what to do with the answer. I am starting here, with my own story, because it is where I first felt the difference between being asked something and being asked about myself.
So I will leave you with the question I wish someone had put to me, and which I now try to put to myself: when was the last time someone asked what you needed, and not only what was in your way?




Comments